Photo Credit: Glen Ellyn Public Library
Since yesterday’s post contributed to my best day ever of site views and is currently the second most viewed post I’ve written and has the most comments of any single post, I wanted today’s post to be kinda sorta almost related. So we get to talk about rereading books!
I mentioned in the comments of yesterday’s post and in previous posts on here that I’ve never once reread any book, except for my own. Why? Because there are so many books that I’ll want to read in my lifetime that I don’t want to keep reading a book or a few books over and over again. I mean, I just don’t understand the reasoning behind reading a book that you already know. Sure, maybe you haven’t picked it up in a few months or even years, but once you start reading you realize how well you already know the story. That is no longer entertainment, it’s boring.
Are there books on my shelves that I’d like to reread? Of course. Are there books on my shelves that I read so long ago that I have no idea what they’re even about? Yes. But will I be going back through my own little library any time soon to reread either of those types of books? Nope.
I know I’m going to be in the minority a second day in a row, but that’s okay. Tell me why you reread books. And don’t you dare just say that there are some books that are so great that you have to reread them. We’ve all read great books. If that’s your reasoning, get away from me.
Its simple. A great book is not always absorbed in one sitting and a second or third view will bring forth details or arcs that were glossed over initially. Also, a good book is like a good movie. When you want something familiar and something you know will deliver there is always that one or several books you know you can count on. Although I’m sure you probably don’t rewatch movies either.
LikeLike
One should never assume things they don’t know. I’ve seen The Hunger Games a million times. And Good Will Hunting. And Anchorman. And all three Transformers movies. And Scarface. And a million others.
LikeLike
Touch’e … Rereading books is pretty much the same then… My favorite to reread is Bad Brains by Kathe Koja. An amazing psychology journey in madness. It never gets old. Also anything by Clive Barker. His books are extremely intricate and ALWAYS give you something new each time you read them.
LikeLike
Nope.
LikeLike
Why nope. Are you purposely being obtuse? Please expand your thought process.
LikeLike
Books and movies aren’t the same.
LikeLike
You have a very strict black/white view of the literary and visual arts and how intertwined they are with each other. This confounds me…..
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve written about this. Spending three or four or six hours reading a book is not the same as watching a 90 minute movie. Feel free to keep commenting, but nothing you say is going to change that.
LikeLike
You’re right, John. Reading a book isn’t the same as watching a movie. It’s better. And so the reason why I like to watch certain movies again and again and never get sick of them is the same reason I like to read the same books over and over and never get sick of them. Because I love them, and I love their stories, and I love revisiting that world over and over. Like watching a movie I love but amped up to a million.
LikeLike
We mostly agree. Just not on the reading a book over and over. I’ll never be doing that.
LikeLike
You make a good point. I’ve got two bookcases full of books that I’ve read which I’m keeping in case I ever want to read them again, but so far haven’t got round to.
I think a good book can be like an old friend and you’re sorry to part with it. And there’s always that niggling feeling in your head (well in mine anyway!) that you might want to read it again some day so you better keep it. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well I’ve never gotten rid of or donated any of my books. And I never will. But maybe when I’m pike 75 I’ll go through and reread all my books. No sooner.
LikeLike
I reread my favorite books all the time. I have a weird obsession with Gone with the Wind and have read it multiple times and always learn something new each time. I typically read classic and it sometimes takes multiple reads to catch the meaning behind everything. Also when I’m done with a great book I’m not ready to let go of the world and reread it in an attempt to get back. That being said a book has to be pretty great in order for me to bother rereading it, but those few amazing ones I pick up all the time and really stick with me. I agree its not really the same as a movie, I re-watch lots of movies I don’t like that much just because they are playing on TV and it only kills time for an hour or two.
LikeLike
I’ve read like zero classics. Okay, maybe a handful. Never reread any of them. At least we agree with the TV thing.
LikeLike
I don’t reread a lot, but when I find a book that I get a good connection with I like to reexamine the occasionally . I think I get a little too emotionally connected to some of the books I read and every once in a while, depending what’s going on in my life, I like to revisit those relationships. I also read books really fast, so when I reread them I notice a lot of things I missed the first time which adds nuances to the story. Maybe you just have a much better memory than the rest of us and that’s why you get bored rereading!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well a couple things here. My life has absolutely nothing to do with my reading. Second, I don’t get bored rereading because I’ve never once done. I don’t see the point.
LikeLike
It’s a personal preference thing obviously. I don’t reread everything though, just my favorites.
LikeLike
And I bet you know all those stories so well that you alwaya know what’s coming.
LikeLike
Yes, but I still enjoy them. And I usually don’t read them annually or anything, so the finer points I’ve usually forgotten and I always love discovering new little tid bits that I missed in previous reads or have forgotten.
LikeLike
Hmm. Okay.
LikeLike
I don’t like to watch movies I’ve already seen, and I don’t like to re-read books I’ve already read. The only reason I might do this is for learning purposes. I might want to see how the author writes dialogue, or describes a setting, or handles transitions. Even so, I don’t usually read the whole book over again, just sections of it.
On my own blog, I recently wrote a post on conflict. I praised author Mary Kay Andrew’s ability to keep up conflict throughout her novel. I scanned several chapters and may do so again in order to study the author’s style.
LikeLike
Thank you! There is a book God.
LikeLike
To me re-reading books is like re-watching a great movie. It will never be as good as the first time because you know how it ends, but you still love the story and it is still entertaining to watch. I have read certain books like 7 times over! They are just so GOOD 😉 hahaha! I do have to wait a while (just like with a movie) to re-read….definitely can’t read the last sentence and five minutes later start over. It is usually at least 6+ months before I can re-read anything.
LikeLike
I agree with your first sentence. Then it’s all downhill from there. Haha
LikeLike
Lol!
LikeLike
I will only buy books I plan to reread. And I usually read them from the library before I buy them. Some stories are timeless, like the ones that influenced me as a kid: Little Women, Anne of Green Gables. Others I just sucked completely sucked into and try to relive how I felt when I first read them, like Hunger Games (yep, no shame here!).
LikeLike
Only buy books you plan to reread? And what if you’re reading an author or genre you’ve never read before? Then how the heck can you possibly know that you’ll reread it? I’m obsessed with THG, still haven’t reread the books.
LikeLike
There are just some books which make you feel nostalgic and that you want to re-read just to re-experience what you felt at the time and what was going on in your life at the time when you first read that book. Personally, I agree with you that there isn’t really much point in re-reading books just to re-live the story but it can be enjoyable just to relish in memories of the first time you read those precious books to you.
LikeLike
I thought I agreed with you, but then I didn’t think so. So we’re just at a standstill.
LikeLike
I guess there are more than two ways to look at whether it is good to re-read books or not
LikeLike
Probably. Doesn’t mean I’m going to adopt the practice.
LikeLike
Each to their own, I don’t usually either.
LikeLike
Okay, I’m totally with you (again) on this one. I don’t know if I’ve ever reread a book in my life. Except, maybe the Harry Potters. But personally, a book is so different than a movie, in so many ways. It’s hard for me to get sucked if I’ve read it before, unless it’s been years and years since I’ve read it, and even then I agree that we remember more than we think. Also, just because of the time factor. I have three dozen books on my TBR list at one time, let alone trying to reread old ones? No thanks. I already know and love that story, I want to find new ones to know and love too.
LikeLike
Marry me. We always agree! Haha
LikeLike
Hahahah except when were threatening to kill each other but you know
LikeLike
Nope. I’ve never done that. It’s you! I threatened your coffee. You’re the violent one.
LikeLike
Hmm. You may be right. Maybe you shouldn’t, I might kill you in my sleep.
LikeLike
You can’t kill me if you’re sleeping, crazy. You mean in my sleep. And no you wouldn’t. I’d sleep with your favorite coffee by the bed. 🙂
LikeLike
Oooh. Good strategy. I think I’ve been beat
LikeLike
🙂 but I have no ring. I’ll give you my college class ring. It’s ginormous and 10k gold. Probably won’t even fit, but you’ll just have to deal. Okay? Okay.
LikeLike
Hahahaha coffee, ninjas, marriage….our conversations always crack me up
LikeLike
Then your answer must be no? Great. I don’t want to talk to you. Ever again. 😦
LikeLike
Oh 😦 okay…Guess I won’t be reading your book then..
LikeLike
No. I’d rather you find a tall building. Get in the elevator. Rise to the top floor. And, well you know the rest.
LikeLike
😦 okay
LikeLike
Wellll I’m obviously kidding. 🙂 Who the heck would make me laugh all the time? Okay, Jennifer Lawrence does, but I need someone else too.
LikeLike
Hahaha well dang I’m only beat by JLaw? Ill take it 🙂
LikeLike
Well she beats everyone. And there are probably others too, but no point in making you feel too bad. 😉
LikeLike
Hahaha 🙂
LikeLike
I was going to start this off with saying I have a small collection of books I reread, but then I started counting and it’s easily 200… whoops. I look at rereading books as somewhat like having a pet. Dog in this case. Dogs really don’t do anything for you but give you love when you want it. They are there when you want a hug and they always bring pleasure… well except when they make a mess or whatnot.
Books are kind of like that. They are a familiar old friend that you don’t have to totally put every thought into when you read it, but it’s comfortable. You know it’s going to end a certain way, so you don’t have the angst of waiting till the end. If it’s a mystery, you know who the murderer is so you are in agony waiting for the kill. And happy books, IE Jane Austen and Nora Roberts and others, well there are so many subtitles that you don’t get first time around. Plus, all the books I keep are ones I admire the writing and use for inspiration when I’m writing.
There are a lot of books I don’t want to own, but that’s what a library is for. 🙂 And honestly, I really agree with jamiewriteswhat and L.S. Engler. Rewatching films and reading the books is pretty much the same.
LikeLike
I have no response to your comparing books to dogs and having reread 200 books and just no.
LikeLike
Well the 50 or so HB Zane Grey’s tend to not get read quite as often, but…. The other’s get a fair share of rotation. Lol, I knew I was going to get flack for comparing a dog to books, and I wasn’t even sure I wanted to, but I couldn’t come up with a better analogy. I reread all the time. I have this one book I read when I was 12 and I read it every year. It’s a simple read it in an afternoon book, but still. Every year. And James Patterson’s Sundays At Tiffany’s is wonderful. I’m a girl. I bet most women reread books over guys. Though my father rereads all his Nero Wolfe’s and Louis L’Amour.
LikeLike
I’m no longer your dad’s son. Not if he rereads. And rereading the same book every year!? Sheesh.
LikeLike
You mock… but oh, those old friends of mine. lol
LikeLike
We’ve already had this conversation before, so I won’t rehash all my reasons for rereading.
I’ll simplify why I do it: Because I can! So there.
LikeLike
I’ll simplify why I won’t talk to you for the next year. Because I can! 🙂
LikeLike
Okay. Your loss. 😛
LikeLike
And remember, that means no more stories.
LikeLike
Okay. I give up. 🙂
LikeLike
Wow. That was easy. I didn’t realize I was so persuasive. I’ll have to log that information away for later…
LikeLike
You aren’t. But you’re nice to me and I’ll need to use your knowledge for when rewrites and edits and query letter time comes along. I’m using you. 😉
LikeLike
Aha! I KNEW there was an ulterior motive to you keeping me around. I’m just a tool to use, eh???
LikeLike
Yes, ma’am. 🙂
LikeLike
Wow. You have no shame.
LikeLike
🙂 tell me a story, please.
LikeLike
Sigh. Fine. I’m so accommodating.
I was a camp counselor during the summers of college. It was an overnight camp in the wilds of the backwoods.
I woke up one morning and reached for my morning medication and the water bottle I used for downing my meds.
I took a swig and felt something in my mouth, but I didn’t think much of it. Pushing whatever it was to the side of my mouth, I swallowed my pill and the water. Then I spit out what was left in my mouth into my hand.
You want to know what it was?
A
LIVE
EARWIG!
I squealed like the girl that I am, flung it to the floor and squashed it flat. Thank God I had my shoes on at the time.
*Shudder*
LikeLike
Ahaha you are simply hilarious. 🙂
LikeLike
Why, thank you. I’m glad somebody thinks so.
LikeLike
That and you’re about the most unlucky person in the world. With your running backwards bonanza and bugged water and footballs flying at your head. Haha
LikeLike
Sigh. I know. But I’d rather people laugh at me than somebody else who can’t handle it.
And it definitely keeps me humble. No ego problems over here, let me tell you.
LikeLike
Haha no problem laughing at you. 🙂
LikeLike
I know. You’ve done it often enough.
LikeLike
I can’t help it. You’re too funny for me. 🙂
LikeLike
If I was TOO funny for you, you’d never talk to me again. I think I’m just the right amount of funny.
LikeLike
No. I rarely laugh at my phone. Even if I write “hahaha” in a text or wherever. But you have me laughing at my screen everyday. I stand by my initial conclusion.
LikeLike
Well, all right, then. I’ll try not to let myself get a big head over that. Oh, wait… too late!
Now, all I need is for something unlucky and painful to happen to me, and that big head will shrink back down and I’ll be my “normal” self again. Except… normal is only a setting on the dryer.
Right?
LikeLike
I don’t know normal. I’m 100% weird, so I can’t help you there.
And that’s perfect. A new story for me. 🙂
LikeLike
I recently reread Jenny Lawson’s book “let’s pretend this never happened” because it was on my kindle, which was in my purse, and it was that or interact with the other parents at wrestling practice. No freaking thank you. The good news is that her book is hilarious and so reading it a second time was just amusing. I even giggled out loud a couple of times, even though I knew what was coming. Given normal circumstances, though, I have too many new books I want to read to keep reading old ones!
LikeLike
Hmmm. I won’t yell at you since you were at wrestling practice with other people around. They’re probably weird. Haha
LikeLike
Very weird. I had to read something to keep myself from giving their shrieking children the stink eye.
LikeLike
Ahahaha I don’t blame you.
LikeLike
If I’ve only read a book once, I either read it recently or I didn’t like it very much. When it comes to my favorites, four or five times isn’t out of the question. And I’m still relatively young. The truth is, there are far more books than there are stories and once I’ve identified someone who sets the bar particularly high in a specific arena (in my opinion) I have trouble getting a kick out of lesser attempts. Unless a book is uniquely original I find myself comparing it to what I’ve already read and if it doesn’t hold up, I’m gone. So as a reader I live in a kind of ever and slowly expanding loop cycle. I’m not suggesting that this is a good thing, or even normal, but it appears to be my lot and I don’t see it changing.
LikeLike
Splendid.
LikeLike
I’m on your side man. I would love to read and reread all day but I just want to read more books different books and as a mom it’s just hard to read at all. The only books I’ve reread were my own and for the dreaded reasoning of editing!
LikeLike
Thank goodness.
LikeLike
I got your back man!
LikeLike
I love rereading books! With every read, I notice something new that I didn’t before, and those are the best moments for me. I love rereading them especially if I have read them when I was younger, to see how much more I understand of that book now.
LikeLike
Hmmmm. I guess. Kinda. Haha
LikeLike
Haha I am being totally serious now. I read Tom Hardy’s Far From the Madding Crowd in high school, and I really did not understand the depth of that book, until I reread it couple of years ago.
LikeLike
I read The Great Gatsby in high school. And I probably didn’t understand the depth of that book. But I haven’t reread it. Haha
LikeLike
Whoa! Lots of comments here. Of course we reread books. Don’t you know they are our friends? Do you only visit your friends once?
LikeLike
I have no friends.
LikeLike
[…] I don’t reread books. […]
LikeLike
[…] On this day in 2014 I published Rereading Books. […]
LikeLike